Question
What criteria will you use to choose a poem? Read your peers' posts and respond to their suggestions.
Let's check out Dakota's post:
We have learned a lot about different types of poetic structures. I like the sound of sonnets. I am going to first think about structure before choosing a poem. I also like somber poems. They make me think. I am going to consider the tone of the poem before making a choice. Consider the structure of the poem and its tone before choosing one to write about.
Create one post that addresses the following prompts.
What criteria will you use to choose a poem?
Give two suggestions on how to find and choose a poem.
Create two posts responding to peers.
Read peers' suggestions for finding and choosing a poem. Post a reply that describes how your ideas differ, and comment on whether their suggestions have caused you to use a different strategy.
Use the discussion rubric to understand how you will be graded.
Peers Post 1:
when I consider writing a poem I first think about what the meaning of the poem is. The second thing I think about is what type of poem it will be, for example there is a haiku which is about nature and has a rhythm of 5 7 5. lastly, I make a decision on how the poem feels and if it even makes sense.
Peers post 2:
When choosing a poem, I like to pick the one I understood the best, one that is long enough to write an analysis on, but not too long. It depends on the person, but I personally like poems that are simpler, and has an easy to understand structure. To find the perfect poem, you should pick one that fits your needs, if you prefer easier to understand structures, then pick a poem with that. You should also pick one that stands out to you. I personally chose Emily Dickinson's poem "I dwell in possibility", because it's the easiest for me to understand.
Let's check out Dakota's post:
We have learned a lot about different types of poetic structures. I like the sound of sonnets. I am going to first think about structure before choosing a poem. I also like somber poems. They make me think. I am going to consider the tone of the poem before making a choice. Consider the structure of the poem and its tone before choosing one to write about.
Create one post that addresses the following prompts.
What criteria will you use to choose a poem?
Give two suggestions on how to find and choose a poem.
Create two posts responding to peers.
Read peers' suggestions for finding and choosing a poem. Post a reply that describes how your ideas differ, and comment on whether their suggestions have caused you to use a different strategy.
Use the discussion rubric to understand how you will be graded.
Peers Post 1:
when I consider writing a poem I first think about what the meaning of the poem is. The second thing I think about is what type of poem it will be, for example there is a haiku which is about nature and has a rhythm of 5 7 5. lastly, I make a decision on how the poem feels and if it even makes sense.
Peers post 2:
When choosing a poem, I like to pick the one I understood the best, one that is long enough to write an analysis on, but not too long. It depends on the person, but I personally like poems that are simpler, and has an easy to understand structure. To find the perfect poem, you should pick one that fits your needs, if you prefer easier to understand structures, then pick a poem with that. You should also pick one that stands out to you. I personally chose Emily Dickinson's poem "I dwell in possibility", because it's the easiest for me to understand.
Answers
GPT-4o mini
### My Post
When choosing a poem, I will consider criteria such as its emotional impact, the themes it explores, and its overall structure. I want to connect with the poem on a personal level, so I will look for one that resonates with my experiences or feelings. Additionally, the style and form of the poem will play a role in my decision, as I appreciate those that exhibit creative use of poetic devices.
To find a suitable poem, I suggest exploring anthologies or collections that focus on specific themes, such as love, nature, or loss. These curated collections can help streamline the search and provide context for the poems. Another method is to read poems from different eras or movements, as various styles can behave differently, offering a refreshing perspective.
### Response to Peer Post 1
I really appreciate your focus on the meaning of the poem, as that’s such an important aspect of poetry! While I also think about the meaning, I sometimes prioritize emotional impact as it relates to my personal experiences, which helps me connect more deeply. I’ll definitely keep your method in mind when looking for poems, especially regarding structure, as thinking about the specific form like haikus may lead to discovering unique and meaningful poems.
### Response to Peer Post 2
I find your approach to choosing a simpler poem really interesting. I tend to look for poems that challenge me a bit more, as I enjoy delving into complex themes and ideas. However, your point about selecting one that stands out personally resonates with me, as that is a key part of my process as well. Your choice of Emily Dickinson’s "I dwell in possibility" has inspired me to explore her work further; her simplicity often hides profound depth, which might be a balance to consider in my own selections.
When choosing a poem, I will consider criteria such as its emotional impact, the themes it explores, and its overall structure. I want to connect with the poem on a personal level, so I will look for one that resonates with my experiences or feelings. Additionally, the style and form of the poem will play a role in my decision, as I appreciate those that exhibit creative use of poetic devices.
To find a suitable poem, I suggest exploring anthologies or collections that focus on specific themes, such as love, nature, or loss. These curated collections can help streamline the search and provide context for the poems. Another method is to read poems from different eras or movements, as various styles can behave differently, offering a refreshing perspective.
### Response to Peer Post 1
I really appreciate your focus on the meaning of the poem, as that’s such an important aspect of poetry! While I also think about the meaning, I sometimes prioritize emotional impact as it relates to my personal experiences, which helps me connect more deeply. I’ll definitely keep your method in mind when looking for poems, especially regarding structure, as thinking about the specific form like haikus may lead to discovering unique and meaningful poems.
### Response to Peer Post 2
I find your approach to choosing a simpler poem really interesting. I tend to look for poems that challenge me a bit more, as I enjoy delving into complex themes and ideas. However, your point about selecting one that stands out personally resonates with me, as that is a key part of my process as well. Your choice of Emily Dickinson’s "I dwell in possibility" has inspired me to explore her work further; her simplicity often hides profound depth, which might be a balance to consider in my own selections.