Question
Why does the pencil look bent in the water?
1. It's because light travels slower through water than through air.
2. It's because the light travels slower through the water than through the air.
3. It's because light goes slower through water than through air.
4. It's because light moves slower through water than through air.
5. It's because light passes slower through water than through air.
-----------------------------------
Which ones are grammatical? Do we have to use 'the' or not? What about verbs? Which verbs can we use?
1. It's because light travels slower through water than through air.
2. It's because the light travels slower through the water than through the air.
3. It's because light goes slower through water than through air.
4. It's because light moves slower through water than through air.
5. It's because light passes slower through water than through air.
-----------------------------------
Which ones are grammatical? Do we have to use 'the' or not? What about verbs? Which verbs can we use?
Answers
Writeacher
There's no need for "the" before "light."
Instead of "slower" (an adjective), you need to use "more slowly" (an adverb) in all these sentences.
I'd say that the verbs <i>travels, moves, and passes</i> are the best and most accurate.
Instead of "slower" (an adjective), you need to use "more slowly" (an adverb) in all these sentences.
I'd say that the verbs <i>travels, moves, and passes</i> are the best and most accurate.
rfvv
Thank you for your help.
What about 'in water' instead of 'through water'?
What about 'in water' instead of 'through water'?
Writeacher
Either preposition will work, but "through" is more precise, I think. It's also more accurate when using the verbs that indicate action rather than simply the state of being.
rfvv
Thank you.
What about the verb 'goes'? Is it possible, too?
3. It's because light goes slower through water than through air.
What about the verb 'goes'? Is it possible, too?
3. It's because light goes slower through water than through air.
Writeacher
... goes more slowly ...
I guess that works, but if you want me to check with a science tutor to be sure, let me know.
I guess that works, but if you want me to check with a science tutor to be sure, let me know.