Asked by Yea
A horizontal pipe of uniform cross sectional area A empties into a bucket, filling it at a rate R (unit volume per unit time).
Use dimensional analysis to determine the speed,v, of the fluid in the pipe to within a dimensionless multiplicative constant of order 1.
What happens to v as A decreases (for fixed R)?
I understand how dimensional analysis works, however when it says "to within a dimensionless multiplicative constant of order 1" i don't understand what its asking for.
In class we were shown that you change distance=L, Mass=M, Time=T.
Where Rate=L^3/T.
Use dimensional analysis to determine the speed,v, of the fluid in the pipe to within a dimensionless multiplicative constant of order 1.
What happens to v as A decreases (for fixed R)?
I understand how dimensional analysis works, however when it says "to within a dimensionless multiplicative constant of order 1" i don't understand what its asking for.
In class we were shown that you change distance=L, Mass=M, Time=T.
Where Rate=L^3/T.
Answers
Answered by
Damon
R = v A (look at a drawing of what you have here)
now the way you are supposed to do it
v = L/T
A = L^2
R = L^3/T = (L/T)L^2
so
R = L A/T
but L/T = v
so
R = v A
now the way you are supposed to do it
v = L/T
A = L^2
R = L^3/T = (L/T)L^2
so
R = L A/T
but L/T = v
so
R = v A
Answered by
Damon
well in this case the result is exact, but in general there could be a constant of proportionality between the output and the input that we could not get from dimensional analysis
for example Force on a plate of area A in a fluid of density rho in kg/meter^3 and speed v in L/T
F = ma --> M L/T^2
= L^3 ( M/L^3) L /T^2
= ( M/L^3)L^2 L^2/T^2
= density * Area * v^2
but obviously the actual number will depend on the shape f the object
so
F = some shape constant * density * area * v^2
for example Force on a plate of area A in a fluid of density rho in kg/meter^3 and speed v in L/T
F = ma --> M L/T^2
= L^3 ( M/L^3) L /T^2
= ( M/L^3)L^2 L^2/T^2
= density * Area * v^2
but obviously the actual number will depend on the shape f the object
so
F = some shape constant * density * area * v^2
There are no AI answers yet. The ability to request AI answers is coming soon!
Submit Your Answer
We prioritize human answers over AI answers.
If you are human, and you can answer this question, please submit your answer.