Why did Theodore Roosevelt think merrily the threat of force was sufficient to achieve his foreign policy goals?

1 answer

Theodore Roosevelt believed that the threat of force was a crucial component of his foreign policy, a principle often summarized by his famous adage, "Speak softly and carry a big stick; you will go far." This approach underscored his view that a strong military presence and the willingness to use it could effectively deter potential adversaries and compel other nations to comply with U.S. interests without necessitating constant military intervention.

There are several reasons why Roosevelt held this belief:

  1. Realism in International Relations: Roosevelt was influenced by the realist school of thought, which emphasizes power and national interest in international relations. He understood that nations often act in their self-interest and that demonstrating military capability could influence their actions.

  2. Success in Diplomacy: Roosevelt demonstrated this belief through several successful foreign policy maneuvers. For example, his role in mediating the end of the Russo-Japanese War earned him the Nobel Peace Prize and showcased how diplomatic efforts backed by military strength could yield positive results.

  3. Latin America and the Monroe Doctrine: Roosevelt's Corollary to the Monroe Doctrine articulated a more assertive American presence in Latin America. He believed that demonstrating American military strength in the region would deter European powers from intervening and assert U.S. dominance in the Western Hemisphere.

  4. Technological and Military Developments: The early 20th century saw advancements in naval power, exemplified by the Great White Fleet, which Roosevelt sent on a world tour to demonstrate American maritime strength. He believed that visible military readiness could enhance U.S. prestige and influence globally.

  5. Nationalism and American Identity: Roosevelt's views were shaped by a growing sense of American nationalism and the belief in the country's exceptionalism. He felt that a strong military was essential to protect American interests abroad and assert the United States’ position as a global power.

In summary, Theodore Roosevelt's belief in the effectiveness of the threat of force as a component of foreign policy stemmed from his understanding of international dynamics, his practical experiences in diplomacy, and his vision of a powerful America on the world stage.