Which example is the strongest topic sentence for a compare-and-contrast analysis?

The Haida creation myth shows its culture’s values by focusing on nature and the importance of animals.
The Māori creation myth shows that this culture values different parts of nature and natural elements more than it values humans.
Both the Haida and the Māori value children, but their myths show that they view humans and human nature differently.
I am going to write about the Māori and Haida and how they view the world both similarly and differently.

11 answers

The strongest topic sentence for a compare-and-contrast analysis among the provided options is:

Both the Haida and the Māori value children, but their myths show that they view humans and human nature differently.

This sentence not only establishes a clear comparison (both cultures valuing children) but also highlights a specific contrast (their differing views on humans and human nature), making it effectively suited for a compare-and-contrast analysis.

Use this passage from the myth to answer the question.

But in no time, the baby grew bored again, and shrieked violently. Finally, the chief gave the child another box to entertain him. Raven, disguised as the baby, began to play even more wildly with this second box. He tumbled it hard, and again it fell open. The moon spilled from the box, and in excitement the child tossed it high into the sky.

The chief tried to catch the moon before it escaped, but it was too late. He resolved not to let the child have anything else to play with. Instead, he decided, his daughter would just have to give the child away to another woman. But the daughter refused. She had grown to love the baby, despite his irritable behavior. Once again, the child became bored, and wailed profusely, his black eyes flashing mischievously like a raven's.

The chief did everything he could think of to calm the child. Nevertheless, the baby cried on, and began to point at a third box in the corner. Before the chief could move, his daughter handed the child this new toy to play with. This time, knowing the treasure that lay inside, the child turned back into Raven, who snatched the box in his beak and flew up through the smoke hole in the ceiling. Once away from the Sky Chief, Raven released the Sun from its confinement. Light shone across the entire Earth, illuminating mountains, rivers, and oceans. Raven no longer had to fly through the dark.

–“The Raven and the First Men –
The Beginnings of the Haida”

In the Haida myth, Raven releases sources of light. What conclusion can be drawn about the Haida’s values based on this part of creation?

Nature is something that must be kept hidden away.
The moon, the stars, and the sun are important parts of the world around the Haida.
The Haida value the sun more than the moon or the stars.
The Haida are not concerned with parent and child relationships.

Based on the passage from the Haida myth, the best conclusion that can be drawn about the Haida’s values is:

The moon, the stars, and the sun are important parts of the world around the Haida.

This conclusion is supported by the emphasis on Raven releasing both the moon and the sun, indicating that these celestial bodies hold significant value in the Haida culture, particularly in relation to the natural world and the illumination it provides.

just wanted to say the answer for the net question is Raven goes searching for women to accompany men.

Use this passage from the myth to answer the question.

Though Tū was not satisfied, the others liked this plan of action, and proceeded to try with all of their might to separate their parents. Rongo, the god of cultivated food and the harvest, pushed with all his might but could not budge his parents even an inch. Their love was strong, and such bonds are extremely difficult to break. His brothers Tangora, the god of the sea, and Haumia, the god of wild and uncultivated foods, joined him and offered their own strength. Together the three heaved with all of their might, straining the sinews of their arms until they collapsed in a heap, totally exhausted. Then Tū tried with all his might, using all of his ferocious strength until he fell to the ground with his brothers.

"It is impossible!" cried Tū. "We should kill them. There is no other way to be free."

"Not yet, brother," said Tāne. "Let me try." The god of forests and birds wedged himself between Rangi and Papa, his back to Papa and his feet against Rangi. Using his legs, he began to move the way trees grow in the forest. Slowly but surely, he pushed his legs upward until his parents were wrenched apart. Papa fell and became the Earth, while Rangi rose up to become the sky above. Light flooded into the world that had been created between Rangi and Papa. The brothers rejoiced, and were amazed to find that in the dark, they had birthed many children – the first humans! These offspring fell to Papa, and were warmly received by the Earth, their new home. Tāne, wanting to honor his father above, decorated Rangi with stars.

–“The Māori: Genealogies and Origins in New Zealand”

In the Māori myth, the children try to separate their parents. Which evidence illustrates the point that the Māori understand the importance of patience and hard work?

Tū quickly gives up, realizing that separating the parents is impossible.
The sons are determined to force their parents apart.
The children fail at first, but work together to separate their parents.
Tāne honors his father with stars.

The evidence that illustrates the point that the Māori understand the importance of patience and hard work is:

The children fail at first, but work together to separate their parents.

This shows that despite their initial inability to separate their parents, they persist in their efforts and collaborate, ultimately succeeding through teamwork and determination. This reflects the values of patience and hard work in their approach to the challenge.

Point: Like the Haida myth, the Māori myth shows evidence that the culture values family relationships.

Illustration: In the Māori myth, children work together to separate their parents and become free.



Based on the point and evidence, which is the best explanation, or analysis, of the evidence?

Best explanation (analysis) of the evidence:

The children’s determination to work together to separate their parents in the Māori myth highlights the strong familial bonds that exist within their culture. This act, while initially challenging, underscores their belief that unity and cooperation among family members are essential for overcoming obstacles. By striving to create a new world where they can thrive, the children demonstrate their deep commitment to family and the lengths they will go to for their collective future. This mirrors the Haida myth, where family connections also play a vital role, illustrating that both cultures place significant importance on the relationships that bind family together and the responsibilities that come with them.

answer is "This suggests that the Māori believe that teamwork helps family members achieve their goals."

Tawhiri, the god of weather and storms, was furious. He saw how terribly sad Papa and Rangi were to be torn apart. He saw the tears of rain that fell from Rangi. Tawhiri raged, and sent hurricanes and sea swells to fight against his brothers. Tāne was driven to hide in his forests, which Tahwiri destroyed with horrible floods. Tangora was thrown into the sea, where he was attacked by the wind and lightning. Rongo and Haumia took refuge in the earth, shielding themselves in Papa's embrace. As a result, Rongo became the god of agriculture and Haumia became the god of wild plants. Caring for the Earth, these brothers remained hidden in Papa's arms.

–“The Māori: Genealogies and Origins in New Zealand”

Which detail supports a point that the Māori believe the weather is a violent force?

Tawhiri, the god of weather and storms, was sad to see his parents apart.
Tawhiri sent hurricanes and sea swells to fight against his brothers.
Rongo became the god of agriculture.
Tū was angry and unleashed his own attack.

The detail that supports the point that the Māori believe the weather is a violent force is:

Tawhiri sent hurricanes and sea swells to fight against his brothers.

This illustrates Tawhiri's violent actions as the god of weather and storms and emphasizes the destructive power associated with weather in the Māori belief system.

Complete the example for the point on which the two myths could be compared.

Compared to the Haida myth, which focuses on creating light and people, the Māori myth focuses mostly on

Compared to the Haida myth, which focuses on creating light and people, the Māori myth focuses mostly on the balance of natural forces and the struggle between family members to achieve freedom and separation from their parents.

In the Māori myth, the emphasis is on the conflict between Tawhiri, the god of weather, and his brothers, illustrating the violent and tumultuous nature of weather while highlighting the themes of family dynamics and the consequences of their actions on the natural world.