When evaluating a claim, the following response would tell you that it is not a good claim:
- The argument does not come to a logical conclusion.
An argument that does not reach a logical conclusion suggests a lack of coherence and reasoning, which undermines the validity of the claim. Other factors, such as evidence lacking testimony or containing both facts and opinions, might also impact the robustness of the claim, but the absence of a logical conclusion is a direct indicator of a poor argument. Conversely, an argument supported by facts and reasons would typically indicate a stronger claim.