This Thomas Nast political cartoon critiques the corruption inherent in the political system of the time, focusing on Boss Tweed's notorious ability to evade accountability. Boss Tweed, depicted as amused and relaxed in the midst of what should be a serious moment of arrest, symbolizes the mockery of justice that characterized his reign over Tammany Hall. The presence of Sheriff Brennan, who greets Tweed with a joking demeanor, suggests complicity and corruption within law enforcement, highlighting how those in power often protect their own rather than uphold justice. In contrast, the looming figure of the Shadow of Justice represents the ideal of fairness and accountability, expressing a promise of eventual retribution with the words, "I'll make some of you cry yet." This juxtaposition indicates a struggle between systemic corruption, as embodied by Tweed and Sheriff Brennan, and the hope for justice, embodying the belief that ultimately, the corrupt will be held accountable. The cartoon compellingly conveys a sense of frustration over the failures of the justice system while also suggesting that this state of affairs cannot last indefinitely.
Use the political cartoon to answer the question.
A cartoon shows a laughing Boss Tweed sitting in a chair next to a desk labeled "six" in a police station. He is surrounded by smirking men in suits. One of the men is tipping his top hat to Boss Tweed. The angry-looking figure of the Shadow of Justice looms in the background with her scales held beneath her elbow and a partially-drawn sword in her hand. A caption reads, "The arrest of 'Boss Tweed'--another good joke." Another caption reads, "The Shadow of Justice. 'I'll make some of you cry yet.'" A third caption reads, "Sheriff Brennan merely nodded to Mr. Tweed, bade him 'Good-day,' and laying his hand tenderly on his shoulder, said laughingly, 'You're my man!' It seemed like a deliciously cool joke, and judging from the faces, it was. --New York Tribune."
The arrest of "Boss Tweed"—another good joke.
The Shadow of Justice. "I'll make some of you cry yet."
"Sheriff Brennan merely nodded to Mr. Tweed, bade him 'Good-day,' and laying his hand tenderly on his shoulder, said laughingly, 'You're my man!' It seemed like a deliciously cool joke, and judging from the faces, it was. —New York Tribune."
In a paragraph, interpret the message of this Thomas Nast political cartoon, which shows Boss Tweed laughing as he is being arrested while the Shadow of Justice looks on. Be sure to read the captions carefully and consider what each character in the cartoon might represent. In particular, what is suggested by the words of Sheriff Brennan and the Shadow of Justice?
(4 points)
1 answer
1 answer