Based on the observations provided:
-
Species X produces CO2 and H2O during cellular respiration, which indicates that it is likely undergoing aerobic respiration, as this process typically involves the complete oxidation of glucose in the presence of oxygen, resulting in CO2 and H2O as end products.
-
Species Y produces ethyl alcohol and CO2, which suggests that it is undergoing fermentation (specifically alcoholic fermentation) and does not require oxygen. This is characteristic of anaerobic respiration.
From these observations, we can conclude:
Only species Y is anaerobic.