"Reagan speech from the Brandenburg Gate"

by Ronald Reagan
Adenauer, Erhard, Reuter, and other leaders understood the practical importance of liberty--that just as truth can flourish only when the journalist is given
freedom of speech, so prosperity can come about only when the farmer and businessman enjoy economic freedom.

Use the excerpt from a speech by President Ronald Reagan to answer the question.

Why is President Reagan’s analogy in this passage fallacious?

He assumes only farmers and businessmen benefit from
economic freedom.

He asserts that economic freedom is promoted by free
journalism.

He assumes economic freedom is analogous to freedom of
speech.

He asserts freedom of speech is contingent upon economic
prosperity.

3 answers

The fallacy in President Reagan's analogy lies in the assumption that economic freedom is directly analogous to freedom of speech. While both are important freedoms, they are not necessarily interchangeable or directly linked. Economic freedom may be important for farmers and businessmen, but it is not the same as freedom of speech. This oversimplification does not accurately represent the complexities of these two different concepts.
whats the answer
The fallacy in President Reagan's analogy is that he assumes economic freedom is analogous to freedom of speech. This oversimplification does not accurately represent the complexities of these two different concepts.