Asked by Ashley
Question :
The cantilever beam AB of length L carries a uniformly distributed W load , which includes the weight of the beam.
(Note that the left end end A is free , while right end has a fixed support)
(i) Derive the equation of the elastic curve.
(ii) Compute the maximum displacement of the beam.
My work :
First I considered a section of beam of length x from left end A and derived an equation for bending moment(M) which gave,
M + (Wx/L)(x/2) = 0
M = -(W*(x^2))/2L) which is equal to EIy' = -(W*(x^2))/2L)
==> EIy' = -(W*(x^3))/6L) + C1
==> EIy = -(W*(x^4))/24L) + C1L + C2 , where C1, C2 are arbitrary constants and y' & y' denote second & first derivatives of y, respectively.
EI is constant.
I found C1 = (w*(L^2))/6 and C2 = -(w*(L^3))/8
==> EI*y' = -(W*(x^3))/6L) + (w*(L^2))/6
==> EI*y = -(W*(x^4))/24L) + (w*(L^3))/6 + -(w*(L^3))/8
For the 2nd part,
I tried calculating max. displacement manually by equating y' = 0 and substituting the x value I got, to y.
y' = -(W*(x^3))/6L) + (w*(L^2))/6 = 0
==> -(W*(x^3))/6L) + (w*(L^3))/6L = 0
==> (w*(L^3))/6L = (W*(x^3))/6L)
==> (w*(L^3)) = (W*(x^3))
==> L^3 = x^3 ==> x^3 - L^3 = 0
==> (x-L)(x^2 + Lx + L^2) = 0
==> x = L or x^2 + Lx + L^2 = 0
But at x=L, y= 0
Hence, x^2 + Lx + L^2 = 0
==> x =[ -L + /- sqrt(L^2 - 4L^2)]/2
==> x = [ -L + /- sqrt(-3L^2)]/2 ] , which are not real values
Following a different process, then I differentiated y w.r.t.x and equated it to 0
EI*y = -(W*(x^4))/24L) + (w*(L^3))/6 + -(w*(L^3))/8
y' = w/24EI(4L^2 - ((3x^3)/L) )
and equating y' = 0 to find x such that max.y can be found,
w/24EI(4L^2 - ((3x^3)/L) ) = 0
4L^2 - ((3x^3)/L) ) = 0
3x^3 = 4L^3 x^3 = 4/3(L^3) ,
which also doesn't seem to give the expected answer of x = 0
Could you help find my mistake?
Thanks!
The cantilever beam AB of length L carries a uniformly distributed W load , which includes the weight of the beam.
(Note that the left end end A is free , while right end has a fixed support)
(i) Derive the equation of the elastic curve.
(ii) Compute the maximum displacement of the beam.
My work :
First I considered a section of beam of length x from left end A and derived an equation for bending moment(M) which gave,
M + (Wx/L)(x/2) = 0
M = -(W*(x^2))/2L) which is equal to EIy' = -(W*(x^2))/2L)
==> EIy' = -(W*(x^3))/6L) + C1
==> EIy = -(W*(x^4))/24L) + C1L + C2 , where C1, C2 are arbitrary constants and y' & y' denote second & first derivatives of y, respectively.
EI is constant.
I found C1 = (w*(L^2))/6 and C2 = -(w*(L^3))/8
==> EI*y' = -(W*(x^3))/6L) + (w*(L^2))/6
==> EI*y = -(W*(x^4))/24L) + (w*(L^3))/6 + -(w*(L^3))/8
For the 2nd part,
I tried calculating max. displacement manually by equating y' = 0 and substituting the x value I got, to y.
y' = -(W*(x^3))/6L) + (w*(L^2))/6 = 0
==> -(W*(x^3))/6L) + (w*(L^3))/6L = 0
==> (w*(L^3))/6L = (W*(x^3))/6L)
==> (w*(L^3)) = (W*(x^3))
==> L^3 = x^3 ==> x^3 - L^3 = 0
==> (x-L)(x^2 + Lx + L^2) = 0
==> x = L or x^2 + Lx + L^2 = 0
But at x=L, y= 0
Hence, x^2 + Lx + L^2 = 0
==> x =[ -L + /- sqrt(L^2 - 4L^2)]/2
==> x = [ -L + /- sqrt(-3L^2)]/2 ] , which are not real values
Following a different process, then I differentiated y w.r.t.x and equated it to 0
EI*y = -(W*(x^4))/24L) + (w*(L^3))/6 + -(w*(L^3))/8
y' = w/24EI(4L^2 - ((3x^3)/L) )
and equating y' = 0 to find x such that max.y can be found,
w/24EI(4L^2 - ((3x^3)/L) ) = 0
4L^2 - ((3x^3)/L) ) = 0
3x^3 = 4L^3 x^3 = 4/3(L^3) ,
which also doesn't seem to give the expected answer of x = 0
Could you help find my mistake?
Thanks!
Answers
There are no human answers yet.
There are no AI answers yet. The ability to request AI answers is coming soon!
Submit Your Answer
We prioritize human answers over AI answers.
If you are human, and you can answer this question, please submit your answer.