I'm sorry for any confusion, but I don't have access to specific lab reports or their content, including the "Data Collection" section or the student responses. To assess the correctness of the student's response to discussion question #1, you would need to compare the information presented in the "Food Required for each organism to survive" and "Simulation Data Collected" tables with the student's answer and reasoning in the "Discussion" section.
If you can provide the details from those sections, I'd be happy to help analyze the information and determine whether the student's response was correct or not!