The correct response is:
The student did x is less than -4, when the variable is on the other side; -4 is less than x so x is greater than -4.
The student's mistake lies in misunderstanding the inequality. The inequality \( -4 < x \) indeed means that \( x \) is greater than -4, and this should be represented on the graph with an open circle at -4 and a shaded region extending to the right (indicating all values greater than -4).