Question

His courage should impress you and (I, me).
me

I already had this checked earlier but now I am thinking it is I because you could say I am impressed but you couldn't say Me is impressed.

Answer 1

Using <i>me</i> is correct. It's a direct object and, therefore, can never be <i>I</i>, which is the form used for subjects and predicate nominatives.

You wouldn't say "courage should impress I" -- would you?

=)