Question

Two electricians came out and agreed on the issue. They let me know the parts I would need and I researched the cost of those parts. At Lowes, the parts will cost $149.73 and on Amazon, the parts will cost $138.47 plus $9 shipping. Neither could tell me how long the job would take due to the size and age of my home. Electrician #1 said he charges 21.45 per hour and has one year of experience in the field. Electrician #2 says he charges $22.55 and has 15 years of experience in the field. Which electrician should I choose?

Answer 1

When deciding between the two electricians, you have several factors to consider:

1. Experience: Electrician #1 has 1 year of experience, while Electrician #2 has 15 years. Generally, more experience can lead to better quality work and a more efficient job.

2. Hourly Rate: Electrician #1 charges $21.45 per hour, and Electrician #2 charges $22.55 per hour. While #1 has a lower rate, this may not be the most important factor given the significant difference in experience.

3. Cost of Parts: The parts needed for the job cost the same regardless of which electrician you choose, so that cost remains constant between both options.

Since the job's duration is uncertain, it’s tough to calculate the total cost. However, considering that Electrician #2 has far more experience, they may complete the job more efficiently, potentially offsetting the slightly higher hourly rate.

Recommendation: Given the significant difference in experience and the relatively small difference in hourly rates, it would likely be more beneficial to choose Electrician #2. Their experience might lead to a better quality of work and possibly a quicker resolution, which could save you money in the long run.