Question
Name: __________________________ Date: _____________ Comparing a Documentary and a Drama: Ruby Bridges’ Story Objective: Analyze and compare how the Disney film "Ruby Bridges" and the documentary "Through My Eyes: The Ruby Bridges Story" portray the real-life events of Ruby Bridges’ experiences in school desegregation. Part 1: Before Watching 1. What do you already know about Ruby Bridges and her role in history? ___________________________________________________________________ 2. What do you think the difference is between a documentary and a drama? ___________________________________________________________________ Part 2: As You Watch A. Comparing Key Elements Fill in the chart below as you watch both the documentary and the film. Aspect Ruby Bridges (Disney Film) Through My Eyes (Documentary) Purpose (Is it meant to entertain, inform, or both?) How the Story is Told (Actors, real footage, interviews, narration) Emotional Impact (How does it make you feel? What techniques are used?) Accuracy (Do you think it portrays events realistically? Why or why not?)
ruby bridges
drama, documantary
ruby bridges
drama, documantary
Answers
GPT-4o mini
## Comparing a Documentary and a Drama: Ruby Bridges’ Story
**Name: __________________________ Date: _____________**
### Part 1: Before Watching
1. **What do you already know about Ruby Bridges and her role in history?**
I know that Ruby Bridges was one of the first African American children to integrate an all-white elementary school in the South. In 1960, she attended William Frantz Elementary School in New Orleans, Louisiana, amidst significant racial hostility. Her actions became symbolic of the civil rights movement and the fight against segregation in education.
2. **What do you think the difference is between a documentary and a drama?**
A documentary is typically a factual film that presents real-life events, often using interviews, archival footage, and narration to inform the viewer. It aims to educate and provide insight into a particular subject. A drama, on the other hand, is a narrative film that uses actors and scripted dialogue to tell a story, often focusing on character development and emotional arcs for entertainment and emotional engagement.
---
### Part 2: As You Watch
**A. Comparing Key Elements**
| Aspect | Ruby Bridges (Disney Film) | Through My Eyes (Documentary) |
|--------------------------|-----------------------------------------------------------------|------------------------------------------------------------|
| **Purpose** | The film is meant to both entertain and inform. | The documentary's primary purpose is to inform. |
| **How the Story is Told**| Uses actors to portray characters, scripted dialogue, and dramatic reenactments. | Combines real footage, interviews with Ruby Bridges and key figures, and narration. |
| **Emotional Impact** | The film creates a strong emotional connection through character portrayal and dramatic tension. Techniques may include music, close-ups of expressions, and emotional dialogue. | The documentary elicits emotions through real-life footage, interviews that provide personal insights, and a focus on the historical context of racism and bravery. |
| **Accuracy** | The film may dramatize certain elements for entertainment, possibly affecting realism. Overall, it tries to capture the essence of Ruby's experience but could take creative liberties. | The documentary focuses on factual accuracy, presenting real events and testimonies, which helps in providing a realistic portrayal of Ruby's experiences. |
---
Feel free to fill in your insights and reflections as you watch the respective films!
**Name: __________________________ Date: _____________**
### Part 1: Before Watching
1. **What do you already know about Ruby Bridges and her role in history?**
I know that Ruby Bridges was one of the first African American children to integrate an all-white elementary school in the South. In 1960, she attended William Frantz Elementary School in New Orleans, Louisiana, amidst significant racial hostility. Her actions became symbolic of the civil rights movement and the fight against segregation in education.
2. **What do you think the difference is between a documentary and a drama?**
A documentary is typically a factual film that presents real-life events, often using interviews, archival footage, and narration to inform the viewer. It aims to educate and provide insight into a particular subject. A drama, on the other hand, is a narrative film that uses actors and scripted dialogue to tell a story, often focusing on character development and emotional arcs for entertainment and emotional engagement.
---
### Part 2: As You Watch
**A. Comparing Key Elements**
| Aspect | Ruby Bridges (Disney Film) | Through My Eyes (Documentary) |
|--------------------------|-----------------------------------------------------------------|------------------------------------------------------------|
| **Purpose** | The film is meant to both entertain and inform. | The documentary's primary purpose is to inform. |
| **How the Story is Told**| Uses actors to portray characters, scripted dialogue, and dramatic reenactments. | Combines real footage, interviews with Ruby Bridges and key figures, and narration. |
| **Emotional Impact** | The film creates a strong emotional connection through character portrayal and dramatic tension. Techniques may include music, close-ups of expressions, and emotional dialogue. | The documentary elicits emotions through real-life footage, interviews that provide personal insights, and a focus on the historical context of racism and bravery. |
| **Accuracy** | The film may dramatize certain elements for entertainment, possibly affecting realism. Overall, it tries to capture the essence of Ruby's experience but could take creative liberties. | The documentary focuses on factual accuracy, presenting real events and testimonies, which helps in providing a realistic portrayal of Ruby's experiences. |
---
Feel free to fill in your insights and reflections as you watch the respective films!