In "Industrial-Scale Farming, Sustainable Path," Miriam Horn employs a persuasive and narrative text structure, weaving together anecdotal evidence and expert opinions to highlight the potential for large-scale farming to adopt sustainable practices. This approach appeals to readers' emotions and emphasizes hope and innovation. In contrast, Courtney Vinopal's "Organic Farming Could Worsen Global Warming" uses a more analytical and expository structure, presenting data and contrasting viewpoints to challenge the commonly held belief that organic farming is inherently beneficial for the environment. Vinopal's choice of structure serves to provoke critical thinking and encourage a reevaluation of assumptions about agricultural practices. Each author’s style reflects their respective goals: Horn seeks to inspire through storytelling, while Vinopal aims to inform and challenge prevailing narratives through rigorous analysis.
In 3–5 sentences, compare and contrast the text structure of the two excerpts. Why do you think each author chose to present information in this way?
"Industrial-Scale Farming, Sustainable Path" by Miriam Horn
"Organic Farming Could Worsen Global Warming" by Courtney Vinopal
1 answer
1 answer