Asked by Steve
You posted a question about having two cannon balls strike the same target simultaneously, with a time delay between shots:
https://www.jiskha.com/display.cgi?id=1520556373
I have had some time to think about it, and have come up with the following ideas. Maybe you have solved it in the meantime.
Since the range of a shot fired with velocity v at angle θ is
R(θ) = v^2/g sin2θ
then if the 2nd shot, fired at angle Ø with the same speed is the same, we need
sin2θ = sin2Ø
That means that 2θ = 180-2Ø, or Ø=90-θ
Our cannonball was fired with v=1000, and the second shot was delayed k seconds.
Since the time in the air at angle θ is 2v/g sinθ = 200sinθ, we need to maximize the distance traveled by the ball. That is, maximize the flight time. This is clearly when θ=90 degrees.
But, that means the ball goes straight up, making it impossible to fire a 2nd ball at a lower angle and hit the same spot. So, pi/4 < θ < pi/2.
So, with a delay of k seconds, we have
200sinθ = 200sinØ + k
k = 200(sinθ-sinØ)
But since Ø=90-θ, sinØ=cosθ and so
k = 200(sinθ-cosθ)
Sanity check: If the time delay is zero, then sinθ=cosθ and θ=45. This provides the maximum range, so no time delay can be allowed. But, we need k>=60
Since we need to wait at least a minute, k >= 60, meaning that
200(sinθ-cosθ) > 60
sinθ-cosθ >= 0.3
Now we know that we need to maximize θ subject to the constraint that
pi/4 < θ
sinθ-cosθ > 0.3
This means that 0.999154 < θ < pi/2
In other words, we basically need θ=1
check:
Range(θ=1) = 90929 -- k=60.24
Range(θ=1.1) = 80849 -- k=87.52
Range(θ=0.9) = 97384 but the time lag is only 32.37 seconds
So, you can see that larger values of θ result in a smaller range, and smaller θ means that you cannot wait the required 60 seconds before firing the 2nd shot.
https://www.jiskha.com/display.cgi?id=1520556373
I have had some time to think about it, and have come up with the following ideas. Maybe you have solved it in the meantime.
Since the range of a shot fired with velocity v at angle θ is
R(θ) = v^2/g sin2θ
then if the 2nd shot, fired at angle Ø with the same speed is the same, we need
sin2θ = sin2Ø
That means that 2θ = 180-2Ø, or Ø=90-θ
Our cannonball was fired with v=1000, and the second shot was delayed k seconds.
Since the time in the air at angle θ is 2v/g sinθ = 200sinθ, we need to maximize the distance traveled by the ball. That is, maximize the flight time. This is clearly when θ=90 degrees.
But, that means the ball goes straight up, making it impossible to fire a 2nd ball at a lower angle and hit the same spot. So, pi/4 < θ < pi/2.
So, with a delay of k seconds, we have
200sinθ = 200sinØ + k
k = 200(sinθ-sinØ)
But since Ø=90-θ, sinØ=cosθ and so
k = 200(sinθ-cosθ)
Sanity check: If the time delay is zero, then sinθ=cosθ and θ=45. This provides the maximum range, so no time delay can be allowed. But, we need k>=60
Since we need to wait at least a minute, k >= 60, meaning that
200(sinθ-cosθ) > 60
sinθ-cosθ >= 0.3
Now we know that we need to maximize θ subject to the constraint that
pi/4 < θ
sinθ-cosθ > 0.3
This means that 0.999154 < θ < pi/2
In other words, we basically need θ=1
check:
Range(θ=1) = 90929 -- k=60.24
Range(θ=1.1) = 80849 -- k=87.52
Range(θ=0.9) = 97384 but the time lag is only 32.37 seconds
So, you can see that larger values of θ result in a smaller range, and smaller θ means that you cannot wait the required 60 seconds before firing the 2nd shot.
Answers
There are no human answers yet.
There are no AI answers yet. The ability to request AI answers is coming soon!
Submit Your Answer
We prioritize human answers over AI answers.
If you are human, and you can answer this question, please submit your answer.