Asked by rfvv
1. He walked away with a golden apple in his hand.
2. He walked away, and a golden apple was in his hand.
-----------------------------------
Does #1 mean #2? In #1, is 'in his hand' an adverbial phrase? Or is it an adjective phrase?
2. He walked away, and a golden apple was in his hand.
-----------------------------------
Does #1 mean #2? In #1, is 'in his hand' an adverbial phrase? Or is it an adjective phrase?
Answers
Answered by
Reed
It's an adverbial phrase. In #1, it modifies the apple, in #2 it tells where the apple was, modifying was. Both 1 and 2 mean the same.
Answered by
Reed
I mis-wrote. #1, "in his hand" modifies the phrase "with a golden apple", which modifies the verb "walked". "with a golden apple" is an adverbial phrase, "He walked away (adverb) with a golden apple (adverb, both modifying 'walked') in his hand (adverb modifying 'with a golden apple'). So, it's an adverb phrase, not adjective.
In #2, as I said, it modifies "was", a phrase called an adverb of place (where the apple was) in both sentences.
In #2, as I said, it modifies "was", a phrase called an adverb of place (where the apple was) in both sentences.
There are no AI answers yet. The ability to request AI answers is coming soon!
Submit Your Answer
We prioritize human answers over AI answers.
If you are human, and you can answer this question, please submit your answer.