Question

What is the difference between little p Progressivism and big P progressivism?

Answer 1

My answer: I think capital “P” Progressivism is the Progressive political party, just like Democrats or Republicans and little “p” progressivism is just a word that describes someone of that mindset, but is not necessarily the same or involved with the Progressive Movement. So little “p” progressivism can be (of a group, person, or idea) favoring or implementing social reform or new liberal ideas. Would this be correct or no?

Answer 2

You have the right idea. But the Progressive movement of the late 1800s and early 1900s was not a political party, it was a set of ideas embraced by both Democrats and Republicans, or the more progressive (mindset, if you will) elements of each party. There were conservatives in both parties, too. When Roosevelt decided to run as a third-party candidate in 1912, his "party" was called the Progressive Party, but it was short-lived. The movement, per se, crossed all party lines.

Answer 3

In other words, the Progressive Movement is often capitalized, but is not the same as the Progressive Party.

Answer 4

Thanks Reed for the info. I wasn't asking about the progressive movement though just asked the difference between little p progressivism and big p progressivism

Answer 5

the first bit of info seems like it would help if the professor ask on the test what the Progressive movement is.

Answer 6

Reed, would this be a better answer:
Capital "P" Progressivism refers to a specific time period, movement and/or the political party (the Progressives) while little "p" progressives and progressivism is “a general political philosophy advocating or favoring gradual social, political, and economic reform through government action”. It is in “left of center in the political spectrum” and “contrasted with conservatism on the right”

Answer 7

That's a MUCH clearer answer! I like it! I hope the prof. does too.

Answer 8

TayB, keep in mind that back in earlier days there were progressives (liberals) and conservatives in both the major political parties. Progressivism advocated regulation of Wall Street and big business for the protection of workers and public safety. Conservatives took a more "laissez-faire" (hands-off) attitude. McKinley, Roosevelt and Taft were progressive Republicans. Wilson was a progressive Democrat.

What has changed today is that the parties have aligned more or less along the same lines (progressive versus conservative) with progressives more in the Democratic Party and conservatives more in the Republican Party. The same debate goes on today, but the parties have realigned themselves.