Based on the verses from the Analects, Confucius distinguishes between moral virtue and profit-driven actions, suggesting a critical view of those who prioritize profit over morality. This perspective reflects a broader societal attitude towards different classes in ancient China.
Confucius seems to elevate the status of the "gentleman" (Junzi), who understands and values moral behavior, while he critiques the "small man" (Xiao Ren), who is more focused on profit. This viewpoint implies that those in higher social positions (like the Shi class, which included scholars and aristocrats) should embody virtue and moral integrity, whereas those driven by profit, regardless of their social standing, are looked down upon.
Among the provided options, the statement that aligns best with this perspective is:
The Shi were held in low esteem because they did not practice moral behavior when running the government.
This choice reflects the idea that Confucius valued moral governance and criticized those in power (potentially including members of the Shi class if they acted contrary to moral principles) for failing to uphold these ethical standards.