From Scratch, by Susie Castellano, and Amy's Metaphor, by Elisa Oh, both center around characters who are struggling with personal challenges and finding their place in the world. In From Scratch, the main character Sophie faces the loss of her husband and must navigate life as a single mother. On the other hand, Amy's Metaphor follows the story of Amy, who is dealing with the aftermath of a traumatic event and must come to terms with her past. Both stories have elements of resilience and growth as the protagonists work through their struggles. However, From Scratch has a more linear plot structure with a clear beginning, middle, and end, while Amy's Metaphor plays with nonlinear storytelling, jumping back and forth in time to reveal key aspects of the character's life.
In terms of style and tone, Susie Castellano's writing in From Scratch is straightforward and focused on depicting the raw emotions and inner thoughts of the characters. For example, in one scene, Sophie reflects on her feelings of loneliness and grief, allowing readers to empathize with her pain. On the other hand, Elisa Oh's writing in Amy's Metaphor is more poetic and metaphorical, using language to create vivid imagery and symbolism. This can be seen in Amy's descriptions of her inner turmoil, where she compares her emotions to a storm raging inside her. Both authors excel in capturing the emotional depth of their characters, but their stylistic approaches differ in how they convey these emotions to the reader.
The point of view and main characters in From Scratch and Amy's Metaphor also offer interesting comparisons. In From Scratch, the story is primarily told from Sophie's perspective, allowing readers to understand her struggles and growth firsthand. Castellano delves deep into Sophie's psyche, providing a nuanced portrayal of her grief and resilience. In contrast, Amy's Metaphor alternates between different points of view and time periods, offering a multifaceted portrayal of Amy's life. Oh skillfully weaves together past and present narratives to reveal the complexities of Amy's character and how her past experiences shape her present actions. Both authors excel in character development, fleshing out their protagonists in a way that feels authentic and relatable.
Based on the comparisons made in this portfolio, I found myself drawn more to Amy's Metaphor by Elisa Oh. I was captivated by Oh's poetic writing style and the way she used metaphor and imagery to convey the emotional depth of her protagonist. The nonlinear storytelling added a layer of complexity to the narrative that kept me engaged and curious to unravel Amy's story. While From Scratch was also compelling in its own right, I found myself more emotionally invested in Amy's journey and the way Oh skillfully explored the intricacies of her character's inner world. Overall, the unique stylistic choices and character development in Amy's Metaphor resonated with me more, making it my preferred text of the two.
Write three paragraphs that compare From Scratch, by Susie Castellano and Amy’s Metaphor, by Elisa OhWrite a paragraph that summarizes the stories and describes the similarities and differences in the plot structures of the stories. Discuss the style and tone of each author as you compare and contrast these stories. (You must use specific examples from each text to support your comparisons)
Write a paragraph that compares the point of view and main characters of the stories. Provide some in-depth discussion of the way each author developed their character(s). (Provide specific examples that support your thinking)
Write a paragraph that explains which story you liked more based on the comparisons you made in this portfolio of the stories’ style, tone, plot structure, character development, or point of view. Don’t forget to support your answer with an explanation of why you chose that story as your preferred text.
1 answer