Write a well-organized essay explanation of what causes Amelia to change her bad attitude toward her sister Annette and not being allowed to go the movies with her. Don't be too simplistic in your explanation. Use details from the text to explain very clearly how Amelia's attitude changed so drastically. You may want to begin your essay by identifying why Amelia has such a bad attitude when the story opens.

1 answer

Amelia's initial bad attitude toward her sister Annette is rooted in jealousy and a sense of injustice. At the beginning of the story, Amelia feels sidelined by her parents’ favoritism towards Annette, who seems to be granted privileges that Amelia craves for herself. The movie outing symbolizes more than just a mere trip to see a film; it represents Amelia’s desire for independence, acceptance, and a personal connection with her sister, which she believes she is being denied. This feeling is compounded by the stark contrast between Amelia’s life and Annette’s perceived freedom, leading her to react with anger and resentment.

Throughout the narrative, however, subtle shifts in Amelia’s perspective prompt her to reconsider her attitude toward Annette. One pivotal moment occurs when Amelia learns that Annette also experiences pressures and insecurities, which Amelia had not acknowledged before. This moment of empathy begins to crack the shell of Amelia’s resentment, allowing her to see that her sister is not just a privileged figure but someone who grapples with her own challenges. For instance, Annette expresses her own fears of not fitting in, and Amelia starts to understand that her sister's life is not as carefree as it seems.

Another significant factor in Amelia’s transformation comes from a conversation with her parents. When they openly discuss the reasons behind their decisions, including why they thought it was best for Annette to go to the movies on this occasion, Amelia begins to see the larger picture. The transparency in her parents’ reasoning sheds light on their intentions and highlights that their choices are not based on favoritism but on guiding both daughters toward maturity and responsibility.

Amelia’s internalization of these insights leads her to reflect on her own actions and feelings. As she reassesses her relationship with Annette, she recognizes that her hostility was largely misplaced and that maintaining a healthy relationship with her sister is more rewarding than clinging to jealousy. This deeper understanding culminates in a genuine dialogue between the sisters, where Amelia expresses her feelings of exclusion and Annette reassures her of their bond. The breakthrough in communication is crucial; it allows Amelia to articulate her emotions while simultaneously fostering a sense of solidarity and support.

In conclusion, Amelia’s shift in attitude towards her sister Annette reflects a complex interplay of jealousy, empathy, and newfound understanding. Initially, she perceives her sister as a rival for parental attention and independence. However, through moments of reflection, conversation, and emotional growth, Amelia comes to recognize the importance of their relationship. Ultimately, this transformation showcases not only the intricacies of sibling dynamics but also the capacity for personal growth that stems from empathy and communication. Amelia learns that resentment is a barrier to connection, and she emerges from her journey with a renewed appreciation for her sister and a more positive outlook on their relationship.