In both "Heart of a Samurai" by Margi Preus and "Black Ships Before Troy" by Rosemary Sutcliff, the heroes are distinctly shaped by their respective cultures, yet they exemplify different qualities that reflect their environments and societal values. While both narratives include themes of honor, bravery, and the struggle against adversity, the cultural contexts in which the heroes operate significantly influence their development and motivations.
First and foremost, the hero of "Heart of a Samurai," Manjiro, embodies the qualities of resilience and adaptability, which are deeply rooted in Japanese culture and the samurai ethos. His journey begins in a feudal Japan, where loyalty and honor are paramount. As he is shipwrecked in the U.S. and subsequently exposed to a foreign culture, Manjiro's ability to embrace change while holding onto his core values demonstrates the influence of his upbringing. For instance, his respect for authority and tradition leads him to navigate between two worlds—Japanese and American—while maintaining a strong sense of identity. Moreover, his remarkable journey to become a whaling expert illustrates the importance of skill and hard work in achieving personal honor within his cultural framework.
In contrast, "Black Ships Before Troy" presents Achilles, whose heroism is heavily influenced by the values of ancient Greek culture, particularly the concept of arete, which refers to excellence and the pursuit of glory. Unlike Manjiro, Achilles's motivations are often rooted in personal pride and the desire for eternal fame. He craves recognition on the battlefield, exemplified by his refusal to fight when his honor is slighted. This reflects the Greek emphasis on individualism and reputation, as opposed to the collectivist tendencies seen in Japanese culture during Manjiro’s era. Consequently, Achilles’s actions—driven by emotions such as rage and a thirst for vengeance—lead him down a path of destruction, which serves as a cautionary tale about the potential pitfalls of personal glory.
Furthermore, while both heroes display bravery, their forms of heroism vary significantly. Manjiro’s heroism is characterized by his willingness to learn and adapt, as he frequently bridges the gap between two cultures. For instance, he takes on the role of a communicator, demonstrating that his strength lies not just in physical prowess but in his intellectual agility and diplomatic skills. Conversely, Achilles’s heroism is marked by his physical dominance in battle; his martial prowess and fierce loyalty to his comrades define him. This distinction highlights how cultural values—Japanese emphasis on collective harmony versus Greek valorization of individual prowess—shape the type of heroism each character embodies.
Additionally, the resolution of their respective stories further underscores the influence of culture on their heroic journeys. Manjiro returns to Japan, leveraging his experiences and knowledge gained from foreign lands to contribute to his homeland, reflecting a cultural commitment to service and responsibility. On the other hand, Achilles’s story ends in tragedy, marking a somber conclusion to his relentless pursuit of glory. This divergence illustrates how Japanese culture often embraces themes of reconciliation and community, while Greek culture, especially in the context of epic tales, frequently portrays the hero's journey as one that ends with moral complexities and personal downfall.
In conclusion, while both "Heart of a Samurai" and "Black Ships Before Troy" feature heroic figures shaped by their cultures, the contrasting values of resilience and adaptability in Manjiro’s character reflect the ethos of Japanese society, whereas Achilles’s pursuit of glory is emblematic of ancient Greek cultural ideals. Through their journeys, the authors reveal how culture not only shapes individual identities but also influences the very nature of heroism itself.
1 answer