Why would it not make sense to accept Jesus as a good, moral teacher but feel that he lied about being God?

Answer 1

Accepting Jesus as a good moral teacher implies that one values his teachings and lessons on how to live a positive and virtuous life. However, if one believes that Jesus lied about being God, it would be contradictory to still view him as a good moral teacher. Jesus claimed to be the Son of God and taught about his divine nature, so if one believes he lied about this aspect of his identity, it would call into question the sincerity and authenticity of his teachings.

Additionally, Jesus' teachings were deeply intertwined with his belief in his divinity and his mission as the Savior of humanity. Denying his divinity would fundamentally change the foundation of his teachings, making it difficult to separate his moral teachings from his claims about being God.

In conclusion, it would not make sense to accept Jesus as a good moral teacher while simultaneously believing that he lied about being God, as these beliefs are inherently connected and rejecting one undermines the other.