why with more negative charges is a balloon attracted to a sweater with positive charges than a wall with negative and positive charges?

7 answers

When a balloon becomes negatively charged, it has an excess of electrons. This charge will interact with other charged objects based on the principles of electrostatics, specifically the attraction and repulsion between charges:

  1. Attraction to a Sweater: When you rub a balloon on a sweater, the friction can transfer electrons from the sweater to the balloon, giving the balloon a net negative charge and the sweater a net positive charge (due to loss of electrons). Since opposite charges attract, the negatively charged balloon is attracted to the positively charged regions of the sweater. This electrostatic attraction is quite strong because of the large difference in charge between the balloon and the sweater.

  2. Interaction with a Wall: A wall, which typically has a neutral charge overall, contains both positive and negative charges. If you bring a negatively charged balloon near a neutral wall, the electric field created by the charged balloon can induce a separation of charges in the wall (this is known as polarization). The electrons in the wall will be repelled, causing the positive charges (due to the remaining protons) to be closer to the balloon. While the balloon may experience some attraction to these induced positive charges, this effect is generally weaker compared to the attraction experienced with a positively charged object, such as the sweater.

Additionally, many factors can affect the extent of attraction: the distance between the balloon and the objects, the surfaces of the materials involved, and their respective capacities to hold a charge. In general, the stronger the net charge difference between two objects, the stronger the attraction between them. Thus, the attraction between the negatively charged balloon and the positively charged sweater will be stronger than the interaction with a wall that contains both negative and positive charges.

Why when you move the balloon to the wall the electrons try to get away whilst the positive charges stay, and the balloon is attracted?

When you bring a negatively charged balloon close to a neutral wall, the electric field generated by the balloon affects the charges in the wall. Here's what happens in more detail:

  1. Induction: The presence of the negatively charged balloon creates an electric field that influences the charges within the wall, which is initially neutral (having equal numbers of positive and negative charges). This phenomenon is called electrostatic induction.

  2. Charge Separation: As the balloon approaches the wall, the negative charges (electrons) in the wall feel a repulsive force from the excess negative charge on the balloon. Because like charges repel, the electrons in the wall are pushed away from the side that faces the balloon. Meanwhile, the positive charges (associated with the protons in the atoms of the wall material) do not experience this repulsion and thus remain relatively stationary.

  3. Resulting Charge Distribution: As a result of this movement, the side of the wall closest to the balloon becomes positively charged (because the electrons have moved away), and the side of the wall farthest from the balloon remains neutral or can become slightly negatively charged due to a lesser degree of electron movement. However, the induced positive charge created by the movement of electrons stays closer to the balloon.

  4. Attraction: The balloon is attracted to the wall because the positively charged area on the wall is now closer to the negatively charged balloon. Electrostatic forces act between opposite charges, so the attraction between the negatively charged balloon and the induced positive charge in the wall creates a net attractive force.

In summary, when the negatively charged balloon is brought near the wall, the electrons in the wall are influenced by the electric field of the balloon and move away from it, causing a positive charge to accumulate on the side of the wall closest to the balloon. This charge separation leads to an attractive force between the balloon and the wall, allowing the balloon to be drawn toward the wall.

What do you notice about the negative charges in comparison to the positive charges?

When comparing negative charges (like electrons) to positive charges (like protons), several key differences and observations can be noted:

  1. Nature of Charges:

    • Negative Charges: Electrons carry a negative charge. They are subatomic particles found in the outer regions of atoms, capable of moving relatively freely in conductors.
    • Positive Charges: Protons carry a positive charge. They are found in the nucleus of atoms and are bound within the atom, which makes them much less mobile compared to electrons.
  2. Movement:

    • Mobility: Negative charges (electrons) can move freely in conductive materials like metals, allowing for electric currents. In contrast, positive charges (protons) are confined to the atomic nucleus and do not move freely in materials, except in the case of certain positively charged ions in solutions or in plasmas.
    • Response to Electric Fields: When an electric field is applied, negative charges move in the direction opposite to the field (towards positive potential), while positive charges move in the same direction as the field. This opposite behavior underscores how both types of charges are influenced by electric forces.
  3. Attraction and Repulsion:

    • Electrostatic Interaction: Negative charges repel each other and attract positive charges (and vice versa). This fundamental principle is described by Coulomb's Law, which states that the force between two charges is directly proportional to the product of their magnitudes and inversely proportional to the square of the distance between them.
  4. Charge Conservation: In a closed system, the total amount of charge remains constant. When electrons are added or removed from an object, the negative charge changes accordingly, while protons usually remain unchanged within their respective atomic nuclei. This highlights the conservation of charge principle in electrostatics.

  5. Influence on Neutral Objects: When a negatively charged object (like a balloon) approaches a neutral object (like a wall), the negative charges (electrons) in the neutral object are repelled, leading to a redistribution of charges. This causes the side of the neutral object nearest the negative charge to become positively charged due to the relative movement of the electrons away from it.

  6. Electrostatic Induction: As highlighted in previous interactions, when a negatively charged object is near a neutral conductor, it pushes electrons away, leading to a temporary separation of charge (creating positively charged regions). This behavior illustrates the ability of negative charges to induce changes in nearby neutral objects, whereas positive charges remain fixed within their atomic structure.

In summary, negative charges are generally mobile, can induce effects in neutral regions, and interact with positive charges through attraction and repulsion. Positive charges, on the other hand, are less mobile due to their confinement in atomic nuclei, and they play a receptive role in interactions with nearby negative charges.

Why do two balloons repel when both have a lot of electrons and less positive charges.

When both balloons acquire an excess of electrons, they become negatively charged. Here's why they repel each other when brought close together:

  1. Nature of Like Charges: According to the fundamental principle of electrostatics, like charges repel each other. Since both balloons are negatively charged (they have excess electrons), they exert a repulsive force on each other.

  2. Electrostatic Force: The force between charged objects is described by Coulomb's Law, which states that the force \( F \) between two point charges is proportional to the product of the magnitudes of the charges and inversely proportional to the square of the distance \( r \) between them: \[ F = k \frac{|q_1 \cdot q_2|}{r^2} \] where \( k \) is Coulomb's constant. In this case, since both \( q_1 \) and \( q_2 \) are negative (representing the charge of the two balloons), the force will be positive, indicating repulsion between the balloons.

  3. Charge Distribution: When the balloons are negatively charged, the distribution of electrons creates a region of negative electric field around each balloon. When you bring the two balloons close together, the electric field from one balloon interacts with the electric field of the other balloon, resulting in a repulsion effect.

  4. Effects of Excess Electrons: The balloons do not just have a surplus of electrons; they also have fewer positive charges due to the imbalance. This further contributes to the negative charge of each balloon. The presence of these excess electrons reinforces the repulsive interaction because each balloon has a stronger negative electric field due to the large number of electrons.

In summary, the reason two negatively charged balloons repel each other is due to the electrostatic principle that like charges repel. The excess electrons on each balloon lead to a mutual repulsion, causing them to move away from one another when they are brought close together.

Similar Questions
  1. Match the scenario to the type of interaction between the particles.Column A 1. Two positive charges are place close together:
    1. answers icon 1 answer
  2. A balloon and a section of a wall both have neutral charges, as shown below.A student rubs his hair on the balloon, giving it a
    1. answers icon 1 answer
  3. Match the scenario to the type of interaction between the particles.Column A 1. Two positive charges are place close together:
    1. answers icon 1 answer
  4. A balloon and a section of a wall both have neutral charges, as shown below.A student rubs his hair on the balloon, giving it a
    1. answers icon 1 answer
more similar questions