Which type of question creates an effective discussion?

Question

vague
vague

leading
leading

close-ended
close-ended

clarification

Answer 1

The type of question that creates an effective discussion is clarification.

Clarification questions help participants explore and understand the topic more deeply, encouraging dialogue and exchange of ideas. They prompt further explanation, elaboration, and critical thinking, which can lead to more meaningful and productive discussions.

In contrast, vague questions can lead to confusion, leading questions can bias responses, and close-ended questions often limit responses to simple yes or no answers, which may stifle discussion.

Answer 2

are you sure?

Answer 3

Yes, I'm sure. Clarification questions are effective in fostering discussion because they encourage participants to expand on their thoughts and provide more detail. They help ensure that everyone understands the topic being discussed, and they can lead to deeper exploration of ideas.

For example, asking someone to clarify a point they made can stimulate further conversation and allow others to engage more fully.

In contrast, vague questions can lead to misunderstandings, leading questions may guide the discussion in a predetermined direction, and close-ended questions can restrict responses, limiting the depth of the conversation. Therefore, clarification questions are generally the best for promoting engaging and meaningful discussions.

Answer 4

i thou8ght it was leading questions.

Answer 5

Leading questions can indeed prompt specific responses and can sometimes steer the discussion toward a particular viewpoint. However, they may not foster genuine dialogue or exploration of different perspectives. Instead, they can create bias and limit the openness of the discussion, as they often suggest a preferred answer.

For instance, asking, "Don't you think that this solution is the best?" suggests that the questioner has a particular answer in mind, which might discourage other participants from sharing their views.

In contrast, clarification questions ask participants to expand on their thoughts without implying any agenda, making them more effective for open and productive discussions.

That said, both leading questions and clarification questions can play roles in discussions, but they serve different purposes. If your goal is to generate exploration and understanding, clarification questions are more conducive to effective discussions. If you’re trying to guide the conversation in a certain direction, then leading questions might be used—but they carry the risk of not encouraging a free exchange of ideas.