Which of these statements is the best counterargument to the claim that sports celebrities are good role models?

Question

Many sports celebrities give money and are involved with charitable causes and foundations.
Many sports celebrities make poor decisions and become involved in public scandals.
Many sports celebrities have struggled and worked hard to achieve their success.
Many sports celebrities live healthy and active lifestyles to maintain their physical condition

Answer 1

The best counterargument to the claim that sports celebrities are good role models is: Many sports celebrities make poor decisions and become involved in public scandals.

This statement directly addresses the notion of role modeling by highlighting the negative behaviors and choices some sports celebrities exhibit, suggesting that these actions can outweigh their positive contributions.