Which of the following charts best compares the goals of “big stick” diplomacy and dollar diplomacy?

“Big Stick” Diplomacy
Dollar Diplomacy
End conflict non-peacefully
Expand U.S. economic interests
Reduced use of military intervention
Establish financial stability
End conflict with military
Establish U.S. military power
Reinforce US control over Latin America

“Big Stick” Diplomacy
Dollar Diplomacy
End conflict with military intervention/force
Establish financial stability
Reinforce U.S. control over Latin America
End conflict peacefully
Reduced use of military intervention
Establish U.S. military power
Expand U.S. economic interests

“Big Stick” Diplomacy
Dollar Diplomacy
End conflict peacefully
Establish U.S. military power
Reinforce U.S. control over Latin America
End conflict peacefully
Reduce use of military intervention
Establish financial stability
Expand economic interests

“Big Stick” Diplomacy
Dollar Diplomacy
End conflict with military
Establish financial stability
Reduced use of military intervention
Expand U.S. economic interests
End conflict by paying off aggressors
Establish U.S. military power
Reinforce U.S. control over Latin America

1 answer

To best compare the goals of “big stick” diplomacy and dollar diplomacy, we need to identify the primary objectives of each approach.

“Big Stick” Diplomacy (associated with Theodore Roosevelt) emphasizes:

  • Use of military intervention and force when necessary to achieve foreign policy goals
  • Establishing U.S. military power
  • Reinforcing U.S. control over Latin America
  • Ending conflicts through military means

Dollar Diplomacy (associated with William Howard Taft) focuses on:

  • Expanding U.S. economic interests through investment and financial means
  • Establishing financial stability in countries
  • Using U.S. financial power to promote U.S. interests abroad
  • Reducing military intervention by addressing conflicts through financial influence

Based on this understanding, the best chart that accurately represents these goals might be something like the following:

“Big Stick” Diplomacy | Dollar Diplomacy --- | --- End conflict with military intervention/force | End conflict peacefully Establish U.S. military power | Establish financial stability Reinforce U.S. control over Latin America | Expand U.S. economic interests Reduce use of military intervention | End conflict by paying off aggressors

Hence, the second chart is the most accurate in reflecting the contrasting missions of "big stick" diplomacy and dollar diplomacy.