The graph that has a rate of change of zero is the horizontal line at \( y = 3 \).
A rate of change of zero means that as you move along the x-axis, the y-value does not change; it remains constant. The horizontal line at \( y = 3 \) meets this criterion since for any x-value, y is always 3.
In contrast:
- The vertical line at \( x = 3 \) has an undefined slope (since you cannot divide by zero), and thus does not have a rate of change.
- The line with a positive slope will have a positive rate of change.
- The line with a negative slope will have a negative rate of change.
Therefore, the line that is horizontal at \( y = 3 \) is the only one with a rate of change of zero.