Which argument of Thomas Paine’s Common Sense was MOST effective in persuading undecided colonists to support independence from Britain?

Question

A.
the idea it was absurd for a smaller territory like Britain to own a larger one like the thirteen colonies
B.
the idea that the king himself, rather than just Parliament, was corrupt and responsible for the unpopular laws
C.
the idea that even gaining representation in Parliament would not protect the colonists from economic exploitation and being forced to submit to unjust laws
D.
the idea that it was unjust for the British government to tax colonists without allowing the colonists to send their own representatives as part of that government

Answer 1

The most effective argument in Thomas Paine’s "Common Sense" that persuaded undecided colonists to support independence from Britain was likely:

A. the idea it was absurd for a smaller territory like Britain to own a larger one like the thirteen colonies.

This argument appealed to common sense and the logical reasoning of many colonists who felt that it was unreasonable for a distant power to exert control over a vast and growing territory. This perspective encapsulated the sentiment of independence and self-governance, making it a powerful and relatable point for undecided colonists at the time. While all the arguments presented had their merits, the absurdity of the situation resonated deeply with a broad audience, fostering a sense of urgency for change.