Gabrielle starts with the equation \( x + 1 = -2 \) and arrives at the first step \( x = -3 \). To transition from \( x + 1 = -2 \) to \( x = -3 \), Gabrielle must have subtracted 1 from both sides of the equation.
This operation can be justified using the subtraction property of equality, which states that if you subtract the same number from both sides of an equation, the two sides remain equal.
Therefore, the correct answer is:
subtraction property of equality.