You need to weigh your evidence primarily when:
C. When the information supports your claim.
Weighing evidence involves assessing the strength and relevance of the information at hand to ensure that it logically supports your argument or position. While considering contradictions and ensuring accuracy are also important processes in forming a balanced opinion, the act of weighing evidence is most critical when you have information that supports your claim—it’s essential to validate that support effectively.
Additionally, evaluating evidence may be important in the context of options A, B, and D as well, but the strongest catalyst for weighing evidence typically occurs when seeking to bolster an argument or claim.