The theme of "A Very Old Man with Enormous Wings" by Gabriel García Márquez revolves around the concepts of human nature, compassion, and the intersection of the extraordinary with the mundane. The story explores how people react to the unknown and the unusual, often highlighting their flaws, selfishness, and capacity for cruelty.
Key Themes and Textual Evidence:
-
Indifference and Exploitation: The townspeople's reaction to the old man with wings illustrates a general indifference to suffering and an inclination to exploit the extraordinary for personal gain. Instead of recognizing him as a being worthy of compassion, they treat him as a curiosity and a source of entertainment. For instance, when Pelayo and Elisenda first discover him, they treat him more as a spectacle than a being in need of care.
Evidence: The townsfolk come to gawk at the old man, drawing parallels to how people consume media today: "They were all fascinated to see a man who was reputed to be a high priest... but they were more interested in his wings."
-
The Nature of Faith and the Supernatural: Throughout the story, Gabriel García Márquez raises questions about faith and belief systems. The old man is initially perceived through the lens of supernatural folklore, yet he embodies more mundane suffering and humanity. This contrast suggests that belief can be capricious, often shaped by convenience rather than genuine understanding or compassion.
Evidence: When the priest, Father Gonzaga, arrives, he dismisses the old man’s angelic presence because of his ragged appearance and lack of eloquence: “This is not an angel. Angels look much better than that.”
-
Isolation and Alienation: The old man's extreme isolation is another crucial theme, emphasizing the ways society ostracizes those who are different or do not conform to expectations. Despite his extraordinary appearance, the old man is left alone, marginalized by the community that initially shows interest but quickly turns to disdain.
Evidence: When the townspeople no longer find the old man interesting, he becomes an object of neglect: “As the months went by... the only one who took care of him was Pelayo and Elisenda’s child.”
-
Human Flaws and Moral Shortcomings: The story also critiques human behavior, illustrating how people's greed and cruelty can overshadow compassion. The family's initial willingness to care for the old man diminishes over time as he becomes a burden rather than a being deserving of kindness.
Evidence: Elisenda’s transformation from curiosity-driven care to a wish for his departure encapsulates this theme: "When the old man stopped eating, she felt the sadness of having to take care of him... she never wanted to see him again."
In conclusion, "A Very Old Man with Enormous Wings" serves as an allegory of human interaction with the miraculous versus the mundane, revealing deep themes of human behavior, empathy, and the often uncharitable nature of society. The old man's presence challenges the community, inviting reflections on morality, belief, and the treatment of those who are different.