what would be the best method for arriving an optimal engineering design solution

agreeing with your experienced engineering manager, who is insistent on
Sticking to the most promising design concept, and
Repeated test and design
Following your instincts until you arrive at a final product

1 answer

The best method for arriving at an optimal engineering design solution would be to combine the input from your experienced engineering manager with your own instincts and judgment. While it is important to listen to and consider feedback from your manager and stick to the most promising design concept, it is also important to trust your own expertise and intuition in the design process.

Repeated testing and design iterations are essential in refining and improving the design solution. This iterative process allows for feedback, learning from failures, making necessary adjustments, and ultimately arriving at a final product that meets the desired requirements and performance criteria.

By combining the insights from your experienced engineering manager with your own instincts and taking an iterative approach to testing and design, you can ensure that you are working towards an optimal engineering design solution.