What was the connection between type of economy and support of the Constitution?

1 Merchants with foreign trade partners typically opposed the Constitution, while property holders supported strong national powers at the federal level.

2Semisubsistence farmers in rural areas typically were suspicious of a strong centralized government, while people living in commercial economies supported national powers.

3Artisans in eastern seaboard cities typically opposed the Constitution, while wealthy planters in the South supported a strong national government with many powers.

4Immigrants who made wages typically were suspicious of a strong centralized government, while farmers who bartered typically supported the Constitution.

1 answer

When?

In the 1790s?
In the 1840s?
Or ... ?