In many literary works, contrasting a character's expectations with their real experiences serves to highlight key themes, such as disillusionment, the nature of reality versus idealism, and the complexity of human relationships.
If we consider a character like Frampton Nuttall in Saki's short story "The Open Window," his expectations before arriving at the country house are often rooted in the idea of tranquility and healing. He envisions a peaceful retreat from his anxiety in a rural setting. However, upon his arrival, Frampton encounters a series of unexpected and unsettling events, particularly the story told by the young niece about her aunt's tragic loss, which culminates in a terrifying experience that contrasts sharply with his expectations of a serene country life.
This contrast reveals several themes:
-
Disillusionment: Frampton's expectations of a calm and restorative environment are shattered upon his arrival, illustrating the theme that reality does not always align with our ideals. His overly optimistic outlook is met with a chaotic and frightening experience, reinforcing the notion that expectations can lead to disillusionment.
-
The Nature of Memory and Storytelling: Frampton's experience exposes the power of storytelling and how narratives can shape perceptions. The chilling tale told by the niece manipulates Frampton’s emotions and reality, indicating that subjective experiences can drastically differ from objective truth.
-
Social Anxiety and Isolation: Frampton's anxiety is exacerbated by his misreading of social cues and his inability to connect with the characters around him. His expectation of social comfort is instead met with confusion and fear, underscoring themes of isolation and the complexities of navigating social environments.
-
Irony and Humor: The humor in the story often stems from the stark contrast between Frampton's initial expectations and the absurdity of his experiences. This irony adds depth to the theme of how life can be unpredictable and sometimes comedic in its deviations from our expectations.
Overall, the contrast between Frampton's expectations and his experiences at the country house serves to deepen the thematic exploration of disillusionment, the complexities of human interaction, and the unpredictable nature of reality.