What are some evidences that VIRUSES are NOT living?

Question

*

Answer 1

There are several key pieces of evidence that support the idea that viruses are not considered living organisms:

1. Lack of Cellular Structure: Viruses are acellular; they do not have a cellular structure like living organisms. They consist of genetic material (either DNA or RNA) surrounded by a protein coat (capsid) and, in some cases, a lipid envelope. They lack cellular machinery and organelles.

2. Inability to Reproduce Independently: Viruses cannot reproduce on their own. They require a host cell to replicate. Outside of a host, viruses are inert and do not undergo any metabolic processes, whereas living organisms can reproduce independently.

3. No Metabolism: Viruses do not carry out metabolic processes. They do not consume energy or produce waste products, which are fundamental characteristics of living organisms. Living cells perform metabolism necessary for growth and reproduction.

4. Dependence on Host Cell: Viruses rely on the cellular machinery of host organisms for their replication. They invade host cells, hijack the host's metabolic pathways, and utilize the host's materials to make copies of themselves.

5. Response to Stimuli: Viruses do not exhibit responsiveness to environmental stimuli. Living organisms can respond to changes in their environment (e.g., moving towards food or away from danger), while viruses remain passive until they encounter a suitable host cell.

6. Evolutionary Evidence: Although viruses can evolve and adapt over time, this characteristic is also observed in non-living entities like rocks or molecules through chemical processes. However, the autonomous adaptation and evolution seen in living organisms is typically mediated by their metabolic processes and reproduction.

7. Lack of Homeostasis: Living organisms can maintain stable internal conditions through homeostasis (e.g., temperature regulation, pH balance). Viruses do not have the means to regulate their internal environment as they are completely dependent on the host.

8. No Genetic Information Processing: While viruses contain genetic material, they lack the necessary apparatus (like ribosomes and enzymes) to synthesize proteins or metabolize substances without the host cell’s help.

These characteristics collectively support the view that viruses fall outside the traditional definitions of life, placing them in a unique category of biological entities.