Volume of Prisms & Pyramids Discussion

Question

In your journal, you wrote about calculating the amount of concrete needed for a building project. You used the relationship between the volume of a prism and the volume of a pyramid.

Pyramids have been used in building all over the world from ancient times in Egypt, Mexico, Italy, and Japan, to modern times in France and the United States. Use your research on a pyramid-shaped building and your knowledge of volume for a discussion giving consideration to purpose.

Begin the discussion by responding to the following prompt:

In your post, discuss the following with your peers:

Identify the chosen building. Why do you think the architect chose a pyramid for the shape of the building?
How would you design this building as a prism? Justify.
How would the change in shape affect the construction of the building?
How would the change in shape affect the use of the building? Use the concept of volume in this post.
Then read two of your peers’ posts. Respond to two of your peers:

For each post, explain why the pyramid or prism is a better shape for the building.
How would you improve on the identified pyramid-shaped building?
How would you improve on the alternate prism-shaped building?
Post a detailed response to the Relationship Between Volume of Prisms and Pyramids Discussion prompt. Then respond to two classmates' posts.

Participate in the discussion to learn more about buildings designed as pyramids or prisms.
please

Answer 1

I chose the Louvre Pyramid in Paris, France as the building to discuss. The architect, I.M. Pei, chose a pyramid shape for the building to create a modern and striking contrast to the historic Louvre Museum. The pyramid shape also serves practical purposes, allowing for natural light to filter into the underground space beneath the pyramid.

If I were to design the Louvre Pyramid as a prism, I would likely create a rectangular prism with a glass roof to allow for the same natural light effect. This design would still provide a modern contrast to the historic museum while maintaining the functionality of the natural light source.

The change in shape from a pyramid to a prism would greatly affect the construction of the building. The structural supports and engineering of the building would need to be completely reconfigured to accommodate the new shape. Additionally, the aesthetic impact of the building would be altered, potentially changing its overall impact on visitors.

In terms of volume, the change in shape from a pyramid to a prism would affect the overall volume of the building. The pyramid shape typically has a smaller volume compared to a prism of the same base dimensions, due to the slanted sides of the pyramid. This could impact the interior space available for exhibitions or other activities within the museum.

I believe the Louvre Pyramid is a better shape for the building because of its iconic and striking design, as well as its practical benefits in allowing for natural light. To improve on the pyramid-shaped building, I would maybe consider adding more green space around the pyramid to create a more harmonious blend with the historic surroundings.

For the alternate prism-shaped building, I would improve it by incorporating innovative design elements to create a visually appealing structure that complements the surrounding architecture. Additionally, I would focus on maximizing the interior space and functionality of the building to ensure it meets the needs of visitors and staff.