To determine the minimum required tail surface area for longitudinal stability, we need to start with the concept of stability in aircraft design, particularly concerning the contribution of the tail to the overall pitching moment.
Longitudinal Stability Criteria
An aircraft is generally considered longitudinally stable if the directional derivative of the static margin (or stability margin) is positive. The basic equation relating the change in the pitching moment coefficient (CM) to the change in angle of attack (α) can be expressed as:
\[ \frac{d C_M}{d \alpha} = \frac{d C_L}{d \alpha_{aircraft}} - \frac{l_H}{l_{H} +\frac{d C_L}{d \alpha_{tail}} (1 - \frac{d \alpha_{tail}}{d \alpha_{aircraft}})} \]
Where:
- \(\frac{d C_L}{d \alpha_{aircraft}}\) is the change in lift coefficient of the main wing.
- \(\frac{d C_L}{d \alpha_{tail}}\) is the change in the lift coefficient of the tail.
- \(l_H\) is the distance from the aerodynamic center of the main wing to the tail's aerodynamic center.
We also need to account for the downwash effect, which affects the tail's effective angle of attack, and can be simplified as follows:
- Downwash Evaluation: We can simplify the impact of downwash on the effective angle of attack experienced by the tail: \[ \text{Effective angle at tail} = \alpha - \text{Downwash} \] Where downwash can be approximated as: \[ \text{Downwash (in degrees)} = \frac{1.00}{10.0} * \alpha = 0.1 \alpha \text{ (for small angles)} \]
Hence, the effective angle of attack at the tail is: \[ \alpha_{tail} = \alpha - 0.1\alpha = 0.9\alpha \]
Thus, substituting this into \(\frac{d C_L}{d \alpha_{tail}} \), we have: \[ \frac{d C_L}{d \alpha_{tail}} = 0.047 \text{ per degree} \]
Stability Derivation
In longitudinal stability terms, we can set the condition for stability which is generally captured via either positive static margin or a positive \(\frac{d C_M}{d \alpha}\): \[ \frac{d C_M}{d \alpha} = \frac{d C_L}{d \alpha_{\text{aircraft}}} - \frac{d C_L}{d \alpha_{\text{tail}}} \frac{l_H}{(l_H + l_{H})} \] Where we denote the horizontal distance based on the given parameters:
- \( \delta x \) is the distance between the center of gravity and the aerodynamic center of the aircraft.
Setting the requirement for stability: \[ \frac{d C_M}{d \alpha} > 0 \]
Substituting into the inequality format we arrive at: \[ \frac{d C_L}{d \alpha_{main}} > \frac{l_H}{l_H + \frac{d C_L}{d \alpha_{tail}}} \]
Tail Surface Area Calculation
The tail lift coefficient can also be expressed through the tail surface area \(S_T\): \[ C_{L,t} = \frac{2 L_{tail}}{\rho V^2 S_{T}} \] Thus, to derive the tail surface area, we will sort:
Setting a corresponding tail lift: \[ S_T = \frac{2L_{tail}}{\rho V^2} * \frac{1}{\frac{d C_L}{d\alpha_{tail}}} \]
Assuming appropriate values for air density (\(\rho\)) - approx 1.225 kg/m³ at sea level, then solving for various potential speeds (typically assumed 65 m/s for safety or cruise for such calculations)...
Finally, you will plug in the values to compute the required \(S_T\).
Conclusion
The above roadmap delineates the method to evaluate the properties needed for calculating the tail surface area \(S_T\). For accurate required values, you should provide specific calculations or speed at which metrics should be based on for L or drag to finalize resultant calculations. The whole basis lies in verifying stability metrics accurately under your design specifications.
4 answers