Option #2, "Why did Jasmine shut the door?" focuses on the reason behind her action, which is related but does not directly describe her actions. The question "How did Jasmine shut the door?" (option #1) specifically asks for the manner in which she performed the action, leading to a more precise description of her behavior.
Therefore, option #1 is the most appropriate for describing Jasmine’s actions in detail. However, option #2 could also enhance the understanding of the situation by explaining her emotional state, but it doesn't focus on her actions specifically.