Use the sentence to answer the question

Question

High school classes should begin later in the morning than elementary or middle school classes

Why is evidence stating that some high school students would prefer school to start later not a sufficient reason to support this claim?

This reason fails to consider why some high school students have this preference
This reason relies on the preference part of the affected group rather than data or evidence proving a potential benefit
This reason excludes the preference of elementary and middle school students
This reason fails to explains how much later classes should start

Answer 1

The correct answer is: This reason relies on the preference part of the affected group rather than data or evidence proving a potential benefit.

This critique highlights that merely stating that some high school students prefer a later start time does not provide concrete evidence or reasoning to support the larger claim that high school classes should start later than those in elementary or middle school. It's important to have data or evidence that indicates how a later start would benefit students academically or in terms of well-being, rather than just reflecting a preference.