To score the student essay using the Georgia Milestones Assessment System, we need to evaluate it against the criteria typically applied to essays in this program, which include:
- Ideas and Content: The clarity and relevance of the thesis, development of the argument, and depth of ideas.
- Organization: The structure of the essay, including effective introduction, body paragraphs, and conclusion.
- Style and Voice: The tone, engagement, and appropriateness of language for the audience.
- Conventions: Grammar, punctuation, sentence structure, and spelling.
Scoring:
-
Ideas and Content (3 points):
- The essay presents a clear thesis stating that schools should maintain a traditional schedule with a summer break due to the benefits for both students and teachers.
- It explores different aspects such as mental health, planning for teachers, and personal growth for students.
- The arguments are relevant and well-developed, though some could be expanded more thoroughly. Overall, it would score a 2.5 for the depth and clarity of ideas.
-
Organization (2 points):
- The essay has a logical structure with an introduction, body paragraphs, and a conclusion.
- Each paragraph focuses on a specific point, contributing to the overall argument.
- While the organization is good, transitions could be a bit smoother, and the conclusion could reiterate the main points more effectively. It would earn 1.5 for organization.
-
Style and Voice (1 point):
- The language is appropriate and clear, and the tone is consistent throughout the essay.
- The voice is present, though it lacks a bit of diversity in sentence structure and vocabulary.
- Overall, it would receive a 1 in this category.
-
Conventions (1 point):
- The essay contains few grammatical errors, and the spelling is generally correct.
- Sentence structures are mostly correct, but there are moments of repetition and some awkward phrasing.
- Therefore, it would earn a 1 in conventions.
Total Score:
- Ideas and Content: 2.5
- Organization: 1.5
- Style and Voice: 1
- Conventions: 1
- Total = 6.0 out of a possible 7 points.
Final Score: 6 out of 7 points.
This student has made a strong argument supported by relevant examples, structured their essay well, and used mostly correct conventions, making it an effective piece of writing.