1. Yes, the answer key is right that the answer is A. Both commas are needed for the very reason given -- that the words between the commas can be pulled out and the rest of the sentence would read just fine and there'd be no significant change in meaning. All the other choices (B, C, and D) would result in changing the meaning of the sentence or causing confusion in the reader's mind. (I, too, don't understand how there'd be sentence fragments in C or D.)
2. A colon should not be used after any verb, including "says" -- http://grammar.ccc.commnet.edu/grammar/marks/colon.htm -- the information and the examples in the box explains this.
Thus, Vlad [could, and did, refer]to himself as "Dracula" and even signed official documents with that sobriquet.
A. NO CHANGE
B. could, and did refer
C. could and did, refer
D. calls and refers
The answer key says: If you look at (C) and (D), you will see that they change the meaning or create sentence fragments, so you can eliminate them. This question is testing commas. You could pull out the stuff between the commas and the sentence would still be correct, so you need the pair in (A), not the single comma in (B).
I don't understand how there are sentence fragments when using choice C and D?
P.S. Is the placement of the colon after the word says correct?
1 answer
6 answers