Chosen Show: "The Handmaid's Tale"
Description: "The Handmaid's Tale" is a dystopian television series based on Margaret Atwood's novel of the same name. It depicts a totalitarian regime called Gilead, established in what was once the United States, where women's rights have been severely stripped away. The story follows June Osborne, also known as Offred, who is forced into the role of a Handmaid—a woman whose sole purpose is to bear children for the ruling class.
Analysis of Gender Roles and Identities: The show presents a stark commentary on gender roles and identities, highlighting the extremes of patriarchal control and the oppression of women's autonomy.
-
Role of Handmaids: The Handmaids represent the reduction of women to their reproductive capabilities. Their names—"Of Fred," "Of Glen," etc.—underscore their identities being tied to the men they serve. This reflects the show's message about a society that commodifies women's bodies and enforces traditional, restrictive roles.
-
Power Dynamics: The character of Serena Joy, the wife of Commander Waterford, embodies the complexities of power dynamics between women as she upholds Gilead's oppressive structures while simultaneously suffering from them. In a notable scene, Serena seeks to control June's pregnancy, serving as a reminder that women can perpetuate patriarchy against each other despite their shared victimhood.
-
Resistance and Identity: June's journey throughout the series illustrates the struggle for female autonomy and identity. Her rebellious acts, whether they are small—like secretly reading—or large—like helping other Handmaids escape—highlight her fight against the gender constraints imposed upon her.
Problematic Portrayals: While "The Handmaid's Tale" is powerful in its portrayal of women's oppression, there are aspects that I regard as problematic. For instance, the show sometimes relies on trauma-porn tropes, emphasizing violent and graphic depictions of sexual assault and subjugation without nuanced exploration of the characters' psychological states. This can desensitize audiences and reduce complex issues to mere spectacle.
Additionally, the show hasn't sufficiently illustrated the diversity of women's experiences under Gilead, particularly concerning race and sexual orientation. While it showcases the suffering of the main character, it draws less attention to how intersecting identities would face compounded oppression within this regime.
What Can Be Done: To address these problematic portrayals, creators can:
-
Incorporate Diverse Perspectives: Future adaptations or spin-offs could include a wider variety of characters representing different backgrounds, focusing on the unique challenges faced by women of color, LGBTQ+ individuals, and those with disabilities under such regimes.
-
Explore Psychological Depth: Instead of focusing solely on traumatic events, the narrative could emphasize healing and resilience, showing characters processing their experiences and reclaiming their identities in the face of adversity.
Overall, engaging critically and constructively with shows that have problematic elements allows for a richer conversation about representation and the need for progress in storytelling.
Peer Discussion Suggestions:
In response to peers discussing other shows or characters, consider highlighting:
- Examples of how specific portrayals reinforce or challenge gender stereotypes.
- The importance of representation in media and how diverse voices contribute to breaking these patterns.
- Potential recommendations for shows or films that handle gender themes and identities more thoughtfully or are examples of positive portrayals.
3 answers