The Glass Menagerie

When is the story set? How is the setting similar/different to today? You should identify two similarities and two differences. Use evidence from the text to support your answers.

1 answer

"The Glass Menagerie," written by Tennessee Williams, is set in St. Louis during the early 1930s, a time marked by the Great Depression. The story unfolds in a small, cramped apartment where the Wingfield family resides, reflecting both the economic struggles of the era and the personal challenges faced by the characters.

Similarities to Today:

  1. Economic Hardship: One similarity between the setting of "The Glass Menagerie" and today's world is the presence of economic challenges. In the play, Tom Wingfield expresses frustration about the monotonous grind of work and the inability to improve his family’s situation, stating, "The world is a place where you cannot find a job unless you know what you are doing." Today, many people still experience job insecurity and financial struggles, particularly in the wake of economic downturns like the recent pandemic-induced recession.

  2. Family Dynamics and Emotional Struggles: Another similarity is the portrayal of complex family relationships and emotional struggles. The Wingfield family grapples with dependence, disappointment, and the burden of expectations. Amanda Wingfield's desperation for her children’s success resonates with modern familial pressures; parents today also often face anxiety over their children's futures and well-being, similar to Amanda’s concern for Laura’s future. Amanda's insistence that her children should succeed highlights a universal theme of parental aspirations that continues to persist.

Differences from Today:

  1. Social Roles and Expectations: A key difference lies in the social dynamics and expectations of gender roles. In the 1930s, women had limited opportunities compared to today. Laura Wingfield's character reflects the societal constraints placed on women of her time, as she is expected to marry and find security through a husband. Amanda frequently advises Laura to be more attractive and appealing to potential suitors. Today, women have greater access to education and careers, allowing for more diverse life choices and personal independence.

  2. Technology and Communication: The setting of "The Glass Menagerie" lacks the modern conveniences of technology and communication. The characters rely on phone calls and face-to-face interactions, which were the norm at that time. The absence of the internet, smartphones, and social media creates a sense of isolation for the characters, particularly for Laura, who is portrayed as socially awkward and avoids contact with the outside world. In contrast, today's society is highly connected through digital means, which affects communication dynamics and influences how relationships are formed and maintained.

In summary, while "The Glass Menagerie" reflects certain universal themes of economic hardship and family dynamics that are still relevant today, it also highlights distinct differences in social roles and the impact of technology on daily life. The play's setting serves as a poignant backdrop for exploring these enduring human experiences.