To determine which rule will have the 12th shape as a circle, we need to look at the repeating patterns for each option.
-
triangle, circle, square
- The pattern repeats every 3 shapes: triangle, circle, square.
- To find the 12th shape, calculate: 12 mod 3 = 0. Since a remainder of 0 indicates the last shape in the cycle, the 12th shape is a square.
-
circle, square
- The pattern repeats every 2 shapes: circle, square.
- To find the 12th shape, calculate: 12 mod 2 = 0. Again, a remainder of 0 indicates the last shape in the cycle, so the 12th shape is a square.
-
rectangle, circle
- The pattern repeats every 2 shapes: rectangle, circle.
- To find the 12th shape, calculate: 12 mod 2 = 0. The 12th shape is again a rectangle.
-
circle, circle, triangle
- The pattern repeats every 3 shapes: circle, circle, triangle.
- To find the 12th shape, calculate: 12 mod 3 = 0. The 12th shape is a triangle.
After analyzing all options, none of the rules will have the 12th shape as a circle. However, if you are asking specifically which pattern has the 12th shape not being a circle, then we would choose the one with two circles before a triangle, which is the last option provided: circle, circle, triangle.