The film clip and Part III of the short story depict the events similarly, but they have some notable differences. Select whether which event(s) are depicted in the story and which event(s) are depicted in the film version of "The Monkey's Paw."

Question

Mr. White knows exactly where the monkey's paw is.

Mr. White tells Mrs. White she must let her son go.

Mr. White says it has been ten days since Herbert died in the factory.

Mr. White tells Mrs. White that the sound they hear downstairs is a rat

Answer 1

In comparing the short story "The Monkey's Paw" by W.W. Jacobs with its film adaptation, here's how the events you mentioned are depicted:

1. Mr. White knows exactly where the monkey's paw is.

   • Short Story: Yes, Mr. White knows where it is.
   • Film Version: Generally, this is also depicted, although the details might vary slightly depending on the adaptation.

2. Mr. White tells Mrs. White she must let her son go.

   • Short Story: Yes, Mr. White urges Mrs. White to accept the reality of Herbert's death and urges her to let go.
   • Film Version: This sentiment may be expressed differently, but a similar moment usually exists.

3. Mr. White says it has been ten days since Herbert died in the factory.

   • Short Story: Yes, this detail is part of the narrative in the story.
   • Film Version: This detail could be altered or condensed; see specific adaptations for variations.

4. Mr. White tells Mrs. White that the sound they hear downstairs is a rat.

   • Short Story: Yes, Mr. White makes this assumption to explain the noise.
   • Film Version: Depending on the adaptation, this specific line may or may not be present.

In summary, many of these key events are found in both the short story and its various film adaptations, though the specifics can vary from one adaptation to another. It’s important to refer to the particular adaptation you are considering for the most accurate comparisons.