The option that best explains the diversity of bird species is:
C. When the ancestral species arrived at the island, there were multiple food sources available, and different beak shapes evolved for the most efficient eating.
This choice outlines a scenario in which adaptive radiation occurs, as the different beak shapes would allow various species to exploit different niches and food sources effectively. This diversity in beak shapes would have been driven by natural selection, leading to the evolution of multiple species from a common ancestor.