Ted is ordering food at a restaurant. One of the ways to order a dinner is to order a combination meal. Meal 1 includes chicken wings and fries. Meal 2 includes a burger and fries. Ted receives chicken wings as part of his order.

Question

Based on the information only, which of the following is a valid conclusion?
A. Ted must have ordered Meal 1.
B. Ted must not have ordered Meal 2.
C. Ted did not receive a burger as part of his order.
D. If Ted also received fries with his order, he must have ordered Meal 1.
E. If Ted did not order a burger, then he did not order Meal 2.
Is it D or E?

Answer 1

It's impossible to tell since we don't know the other ways of ordering a meal in this restaurant.

But, based only on the given information, A, B, C, and E are all correct.

Answer 2

But would D or E make more sense?