Both sources address the decline in religious affiliation and practice, particularly in Western countries like the United States and Britain, while suggesting that this trend is part of a broader global shift in religious beliefs.
Similarities:
-
Decline in Religious Affiliation:
- Source 1 states that in Britain, people of no religion outnumbered Christians for the first time in 2009, highlighting a trend of declining religious belief in Western countries.
- Source 2 mentions that Americans with no religious affiliation have increased from 9% in 2000-2003 to 21% in 2021-2023, underscoring a similar decline in religious identification.
-
Trends in Attendance:
- Source 1 indicates a general decline in religious belief, suggesting a global trend with regions like Israel, Norway, and Japan reporting low numbers of religious individuals.
- Source 2 provides quantitative data revealing that only three in 10 American adults report attending religious services regularly, with a notable increase in the percentage of those who seldom or never attend.
-
Youth and Religion:
- Source 1 notes that even though faith is declining in places like America, many non-religious people still feel spiritual.
- Source 2 highlights that younger Americans exhibit weaker attachments to organized religion, with a significant portion of them (35%) reporting no religious affiliation.
Claim and Supporting Evidence:
Claim: A significant decline in religious affiliation and service attendance is occurring, especially among younger populations, which indicates a shift towards secularism in Western societies.
Supporting Evidence:
-
Decline in Affiliation: Source 1 indicates that religion is in decline in various countries, notably in Western contexts. Source 2 supports this by providing statistics showing an increase in the proportion of Americans identifying as having no religious affiliation.
-
Service Attendance: Source 2 reveals that only 30% of American adults attend religious services regularly, which reflects the overall trend of declining religious practice also suggested in Source 1.
-
Youth Detachment: Source 1 mentions the increase in spiritual feelings among non-religious people, which aligns with Source 2's findings that younger adults are less likely to engage in religious services and have increasingly identified as non-religious.
Summary
Both sources effectively highlight the decreasing influence of organized religion in contemporary society, supported by statistical trends from polls and surveys. The trend—particularly among younger generations—suggests a shift towards secularism, as evidenced by increased non-affiliation and lower regular attendance at religious services.